laa closure do we really need a new device design

4/19/2014
LAA CLOSURE DO WE REALLY NEED A
NEW DEVICE DESIGN
Reda AbuElatta MD,FSCAI
Madinah Cardiac Center
Almadeina Almunawara
SACIS-2014
Conflict of Interest Statement
NON
1
4/19/2014
We have a growing number of options to consider,
including medications and invasive procedures…
AF
If I can’t be in sinus
rhythm, I want to be
safe from having a
stroke.
2
4/19/2014
DEFINING STROKE RISK – CHADS2 SCORE
CHADS2 Risk
Score
CHADS2
score
Patients
(n = 1733)
Adjusted
stroke rate
%/year
CHF
1
Hypertension
1
0
120
1.9
Age > 75
1
1
463
2.8
Diabetes
1
2
523
4.0
Stroke or TIA
2
3
337
5.9
4
220
8.5
5
65
12.5
6
5
18.2
Modified from ESC AF Guidelines
http://www.escardio.org/guidelines-surveys/esc-guidelines/GuidelinesDocuments/guidelines-afib-FT.pdf
REDEFINING RISK - CHA2DS2VASC
CHA2DS2-Vasc Risk
Score
CHF or LVEF < 40%
1
Hypertension
1
Age >65 ; > 75 years
1/2
Diabetes
Stroke/Thromboembolism
1
2
Vascular Disease
1
Sex: Female
1
CHA2DS2V Patients (n Adjusted
asc
= 7329)
stroke rate
(%/year)
score
0
1
0
1
422
1.3
2
1230
2.2
3
1730
3.2
4
1718
4.0
5
1159
6.7
6
679
9.8
7
294
9.6
8
82
12.7
9
14
15.2
3
4/19/2014
LAA AS SOURCE IN AF
During AF, hypo-contractile LAA causes
stagnation of blood flow in trabeculated
cavity
TEE-based risk factors:
 Enlarged LAA
 Reduced LAA inflow and outflow velocities
 Spontaneous Echo contrast
Blackshear: Ann Thoracic Surg 61, 1996
Johnson: Eur J Cardiothoracic Surg 17, 2000
Fagan: Echocardiography 17, 2000
WHY NOT SIMPLY EXCLUDE THE LAA
FROM THE CARDIAC CIRCULATION?
4
4/19/2014
LAA EXTERNAL VIEW
(Pictures Courtesy Prof. D. Sanchez Quintana)
Extra-appendicular
Pectinate Muscle
Extra-appendicular
Pectinate Muscle
Extra-appendicular
Pectinate Muscle
Major
Cardiac
vein
Circunflex
artery
5
4/19/2014
LAA Closure Devices
Endocardial
• PLAATO
• Watchman
• ACP  Amulet
• Coherex
• Sideris Patch
• Occlutech
• pfm Medical
• Lifetech
• Gore
• Cardia
Epicardial
• SentreHeart
• AEGIS
• AtriCure
• Medtronic
Watchman Occluder
•
•
•
•
Nitinol
PET membrane with pores
Hooks
21, 24, 27, 30, 33 mm
6
4/19/2014
Amplatzer Cardiac Plug
• Distal lobe (16-30mm)
•
• Disk (20-36mm)
• 9, 10 or 13F sheath
Lobe length
6.5mm
CardioVascular Center Frankfurt CVC
AMPLATZER CARDIAC PLUG
Feature
Sizes (mm)
ACP
16
Disc Ø
18
20
Lobe Length
Lobe diameter 16-30mm
Lobe length 6.5mm
Disk diameter 20-36mm
9, 10 or 13F sheath
22
24
Lobe + 4mm
26
4mm
SW Ø
0.006”
# SW Pairs
6
Oversizing
1.5-3.0mm
Disc End Screw
PKG
30
6.5mm
Waist Length
Sheath (Fr)
28
Lobe + 6mm
9
10
13
Protruding
Partially pre-loaded
7
4/19/2014
Procedural guidance :
AMPLATZER® Cardiac Plug
AMPLATZER® Cardiac Plug - Notice of Availability - Caution: Investigational device. Limited by Federal (U.S.) law to investigational use.
TEE EVALUATION
16
8
4/19/2014
17
DEVICE POSITIONING AND DEPLOYEMENT
18
9
4/19/2014
FINAL RELEASE
19
Final Deployment of Disc :
X plane TEE ( 45 and 135 degrees)
10
4/19/2014
Before
LAA occlusion with ACP plug
After
Amulet
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Pre-loaded
Recessed end screw
Larger disc diameter
Longer lobe length
Longer waist length
Larger sizes up to 34mm
Stiffer stabilizing wires (.0065)
More stabilizing wires on
larger devices
CardioVascular Center Frankfurt CVC
11
4/19/2014
ACP2 Design Feature Comparison
Feature
Sizes (mm)
ACP
16
Disc Ø
18
20
22
24
Lobe + 4mm
Lobe Length
Waist Length
SW Ø
Amulet
26
30
16
18
20
22
34
7.5mm
10mm
4mm
5.5mm
6
1.5-3.0mm
9
31
6.5mm
Oversizing
Disc End Screw
28
Lobe + 7mm
8mm
0.006”
Sheath (Fr)
25
Lobe + 6mm
# SW Pairs
PKG
28
Lobe + 6mm
10
0.0065”
6
8
3-5mm
13
Protruding
10
3-6mm
12
ACP
Amulet
Partially pre-loaded
14
Recessed
Fully pre-loaded
RECESSED END SCREW


uniform surface in the left atrium
less risk of thrombus formation
Preclinical canine model: Mature and stable
neointima covering the device surface (arrows);
the device was filled by organized thrombus
(asterisk). 90 day cohort (H&E)
12
4/19/2014
FLEXIBLE DELIVERY CABLE
Delivery cable includes an 0.014” inner wire
Enables visualization of final device placement
prior to release
INCREASED STABILITY
More stabilizing wires in larger devices
 increased stability
ACP
Amulet
13
4/19/2014
Final security check prior device release
S C A R
SEALING of the LAA OS
CONCAVITY of the disc
ANGLE between disc
and lobe
REST COMPRESSION
of the lobe
LAA OCCLUSION - CONCLUSIONS

Protective strategies for AF patients continue to evolve with
growing number of options.

PROTECT AF provided first randomized evidence that LAA
closure may not only be beneficial, but prove to be superior to
warfarin.

Best “mousetrap” yet to be determined

Consider the individual risks/needs of each pt.


THE VARIATION IN LAA MAKES ALWAYS NO SINGLE IDEAL DEVICE
ALL SHOULD SHARE THE CONCEPTS
– SAFETY
– AFFECTIVENESS
– USER FRIENDLY
14
4/19/2014
29
15