Download full text pdf

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CIVIL AND STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
Volume 4, No 4, 2014
© Copyright by the authors - Licensee IPA- Under Creative Commons license 3.0
Research article
ISSN 0976 – 4399
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab
– with and without embossments
1
Merool D. Vakil1, Japan U. Shah2, H.S.Patel3
Assistant Professor, Applied Mechanics Department, Government Engineering College,
Patan, Gujarat, India.
2
P.G. Student Applied Mechanics Department, L.D. College of Engineering,
Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
3
Professor, Applied Mechanics Department, Government Engineering College, Patan,
Gujarat, India.
Doi: 10.6088/ijcser.201404040001
ABSTRACT
Many efforts have been made by the researchers to forecast the strength of composite slab
experimentally. The experimental methods based on the full-size test are expensive, time
consuming and semi-empirical. This paper describes a study on finite element modelling
of composite slab numerically. The aim is to understand the deflection characteristics of
steel–concrete composite deck in order to improve designs for steel decking for composite
slabs. 3-D finite element slab model is built, with and without embossments on profile
deck. Analysis is carried out on simply supported composite slab under two point line
loads by varying parameters: concrete height and concrete grade. It has been observed that
composite slab without embossment deformed more as compared to slab with embossment.
Keywords: Composite slab, FEM analysis, ANSYS, Embossments, Concrete height,
Grade of concrete.
1. Introduction
A composite slab with profiled steel decking is considered as one of the simpler, faster,
lighter and economical constructions in steel-framed building systems. The system is
well recognized by the construction industry due to many advantages such as, no
formwork, quick installation, and reduced dimensions and weight. Composite floors with
profiled decking consist of the profiled decking, shear connectors, reinforcement for
shrinkage and temperature stresses and concrete. For the steel deck and concrete to act
compositely, a mechanical interlocking is needed. This is provided essentially by shear
transferring mechanism such as rolled embossments, indentation, holes or by dovetail
shape of the profile. Figure-1 shows schematic view of the composite slab. This paper,
aims to study the deformation of composite slabs considering with embossment and
without embossment profile sheetby the varying concrete height and grade of concrete
numerically.
2. Description of the FEM model for composite deck slab
The objective of this work is to evaluate the dependency of deflection on embossment,
material and geometric parameters so; these numerical models have been parametrically
built. The finite element (FE) method is one of the powerful tools to study the behaviour
of the composite slabs. Total 18 models are modelled in ANSYS-15 to identify the
Received on December, 2013 Published on May2014
477
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab – with and without embossments
Merool D
deformation of the composite slab considering different parameters. Concrete is modelled
by SOLID65 element. This element can be used for the 3-D modelling of solids with or
without reinforcing bars. The solid is capable of cracking in tension and crushing in
compression. The element is defined by eight nodes having three degrees of freedom at
each node: translations in the nodal x, y, and z directions. Profile deck is modelled with
SHELL181 element. It is used for analysing thin to moderately-thick shell structures. It is
a 4-node element with six degrees of freedom at each node: translations in the x, y, and z
directions, and rotations about the x, y, and z-axes.
Figure1: Composite floor system
2.1 Material Properties of FE Model
Bilinear Isotropic property was used for profile Sheet. Multi linear Isotropic material
properties were used for concrete. The material properties are listed in Table – 1
Table 1: Material property
Density
Poisson’s ratio
Elastic modulus
Yield strength
Structural steel property
7850 kg/m3
0.3
2x105 N/mm2
250 N/mm2
Table 2: Material property
Concrete property
Density
2300 kg/m3
Poisson’s ratio
0.18
Elastic modulus
25000 N/mm2
Compressive Cube strength
25
N/mm2
2.2 Geometric parameters of FE model
In this study, thickness of the profile deck 0.9 mm, the span of the composite slab 2400mm
and width 450 mm is considered. The shape and dimensions of the deck sheet are shown in
478
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
Volume 4 Issue 4 2014
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab – with and without embossments
Merool D
Figure-2. Different depth of the slab like 110 mm, 120 mm, 130 mm, 140 mm and 150mm
is considered in this analysis. The embossments were modelled with the help of PRO
Engineer (Pro-E) software. A punch tool was modelled with exact dimensions of
embossments. The same tool had been used over the sheet metal module to form the
embossment over the profiled deck sheet. The model was imported into ANSYS software
and the properties were assigned. Embossments were projected for 3 mm towards the
concrete portion as. The embossments were spaced at 65 mm c/c and placed along the
length of the sheet as shown in Figure-3. The square dimensions are 25mm x 25mm
considered for embossment. By variation in concrete mix for different grade of concrete
like M25, M30, M35, M40, and M45 the finite element analysis is carried out.
Figure2: Trapezoidal profile sheet
Figure 3: Pro-E Geometry with
Embossment (sheet metal)
2.3 Loading and Boundary Condition of FE model
Two wavelength of the composite slab was considered in finite element analysis. A static
load of 20 kN was applied as two line load at distance of 600mm from each of the support.
The standard gravity of the materials was included in the model. Mesh refinement is done
to whole composite slab as shown in Figure-4. Bonded connection between profile steel
sheet and concrete was considered. A simply supported boundary condition was assumed
for the composite deck slab, one end considered as hinged support and other end as a roller
support.
Figure 4: Meshing of Composite slab
479
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
Volume 4 Issue 4 2014
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab – with and without embossments
Merool D
3. Results and Discussion
The parametric study was conducted with the different concrete height and con crete
grade and the total deflection at mid-span of the composite slab has been observed.
Deflection contours of profile deck with and without embossments are shown in Figure
-5 for 110 mm height of slab and M25 grade of concrete. Table 2 shows deflection
variation of slab with and without embossment by varying concrete height. Table 3
shows deflection variation of slab with and without embossment by varying concrete
grade.
Without embossment
with embossment
Figure5: Deflection contour of 110 mm height of slab and M25 grade of concrete
Table 3: FE analysis results of deformation with a variation in concrete height
Description
Concrete height
Without
Embossment
With
Embossment
Deformation (mm)
110
mm
13.85
8.24
120mm
10.81
6.59
130mm
140mm
8.57
6.91
5.47
4.61
150mm
5.67
3.99
Table 4: FE analysis results of deformation with a variation in concrete grade
Description
Deformation (mm)
Concrete Grade
M25
Without
Embossment
13.85
With
Embossment
8.24
M30
12.92
7.56
M35
M40
12.14
11.51
7.06
6.67
M50
10.98
6.36
480
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
Volume 4 Issue 4 2014
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab – with and without embossments
Merool D
3.1 Results of various parameters are summarized as follows:
1) The concrete height has a considerable effect on the deflection of composite slab. It is
observed that deflection decreases by 14% to20% as the height is increased from 110
mm to150 mm in WE Sheet.
2) In WOE composite slab deformation reduces by18% to 22% as the height is increased
from 110mm to 150 mm.
3) Comparing the WOE and WE, it is observed that the WE composite slab has less
deformation by almost 30% to 41 % as the concrete height is increased from 110mm
to 150 mm.
4) When deformation of WE is calculated by varying different grade of concrete from
M25 to M45, it is reduced by 5% to 8%.
5) In WOE slab deformation reduces by 4% to 6 % as the grade increased by M25 to
M45.
6) When the deformation of WOE with WE sheet is compared by considering different
grade of concrete from M25 to M45, it is reduced by 41% to 42%
4. Conclusions
A parametric study of 18 composite decks with and without embossment was performed
using the finite element analyses. Square shape embossment and no embossment
composite deck were studied for different concrete height and concrete mix. A deflection
characteristic of composite deck is studied for these variations. Deflection in slab without
embossment was found higher than deflection in slab with embossment. It is observed
that, while comparing WOE slab with WE slab, the WE composite slab has almost 30% to
41 % less deformation as the concrete height is increased and 41% to 42% as the concrete
mix is increased. There was a significant decrease in deflection by varying concrete height
rather than by varying concrete mix for WE and WOE slab. This is due to increase in
moment of inertia of the section.
5. References
1. ANSYS User’s manual.
2. Chen, S., (2003), Load carrying capacity of composite slabs with various end
constraints, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 59, pp 385-403.
3. EN 1994-1-1 (2004). Euro code 4: design of composite steel and concrete
structures. Part 1.1: general rules and rules for buildings. Brussels: European
Committee for Standardization.
4. Euripides S. Mistakidis, (2009), Bending resistance of composite slabs made with
thin-walled steel sheeting with indentations or Embossments, Thin-Walled
Structures, 46, pp 192–206.
5. Johnson R. P., (2004), Composite structures of steel and concrete beams, slabs,
columns, and frames for buildings, 3rd Edition Oxford, United Kingdom:
Blackwell Scientific Publications.
481
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
Volume 4 Issue 4 2014
Numerical study on deformation characteristics of composite slab – with and without embossments
Merool D
6. Marimuthu V, (2007), Experimental studies on composite deck slabs to determine
the shear-bond characteristic (m-k) values of the Embossed profiled sheet, Journal
of Constructional Steel Research, 63(6), pp 791–803.
7. Miquel Ferrer, (2006), Designing cold-formed steel sheets for composite slabs: An
experimentally validated FEM approach to slip failure Mechanics, Thin-Walled
Structures, 44, pp 1261–1271.
8. Pentti Makelainen, (1999), The longitudinal shear behaviour of a new steel sheeting
profile for composite floor slabs, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 49, pp
117–128.
9. Shiming Chen, (2011), Shear bond mechanism of composite slabs - A universal FE
approach, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 67 b, pp 1475–1484.
482
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
Volume 4 Issue 4 2014