2
ফা
ূপள੶ൡ
ਸ਼&63+25ফভ
َ42/௬भਈ عফभஷॉନॉध০भனُع
4$/<4XDOLW\$GMXVWHG/LIH<HDU
z
৽ৎ৷கभශ৲એ
েோফਯ॑42/৷கदातऐ
4$/<भੰෲपঢ়ॎॊ
ଁੑऩਖ
ຠ⏝್
1
ূপ৾প৾ ୢ৾௺ଢ଼ఐ
೨ఐ่৾؞૧৾௧వ েଁੑ৾ী
༖ਉ೨
䛺ᗣ
᭤⥺㠃✚
䠙QALY
0
েோফਯध42/॑
ৎपઅൟ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
3
4
5&7ॹ॑ॱش৷ःञ4$/<भଁੑੰෲ
z
ষअधऌ
ಏ෫ଢ଼भ೨ঢ়৴42/॔क़ॺढ़धखथ
¾ ਤষ᷈ቅदभ*(67ୡ 8HQRHWDO-&2
ા৷ટীෲभટधखथ
¾ ৣ⍴ንᯂदभ9HQ86
¾ হधखथງஂ
z
,,ୡ 6RDUHV HWDO%0-
z […], median QALY were 0.401 in the
gemcitabine group, […]
z The QALY value in the GS group was
significantly better than that in the
gemcitabine group (P<.001).
মभਵ
ୡभીവऩन॑৶पखञઊठજॉ
ঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତ
5
হৣ؟⍴ንᯂपৌघॊ
ঐ०ॵॺ১क़४དभા৷ટীෲ
॔क़ॺছॖথ
z
6
হງஂ
9HQ86
,,ୡॹ॑ॱش৷ःञા৷ટীෲ
ଁੑੰෲभ੶ൗ
z
ଁੑୖ
ઊठજॉॹॱشध4$/<भଁੑੰෲ
ঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତ
z
হदभટधऽधी
7
হৣ؟⍴ንᯂपৌघॊ
ঐ०ॵॺ১क़४དभા৷ટীෲ
z
হदभଁੑੰෲभ੶ൗ
9HQ86 ,,ছথॲ৲ୡ
ঐ०ॵॺ১
୯؟ਈপऊা
YVঁॖॻট।ঝ
¾ ીೕपఃஈऔोञ೩मعऊাभ୯
¾ عऊাभँःटप୯ીവऋে
¾ ଈಝमऺऻऩख
৷கभ
Dumville et al. BMJ 2009.
Soares et al. BMJ 2009.
¾ (4'दؚؚؚؚऊা৯
z
8
ऊাऽदभ4$/<॑ଁੑੰෲ
ા৷ટীෲभટधखथ
z We used inverse probability weighting to
estimate the mean […] QALYs, accounting for
the censored nature of these data.
z The weights were evaluated as the inverse of
Kaplan Meier estimator of censoring probability.
z For QALYs […], we partitioned the study time
horizon in homogenous subintervals (quarterly
intervals) […]
z Linear regression was used […]. We included
baseline EQ-5D scores as a covariate in the
estimation of QALYs.
9
๕ऩ5&7भॹॱشଡୗ
ᝈ⪅ID
ほᐹ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
⩌
0䛛᭶䛾
ຠ⏝್
Ṛஸ
䛒䜚
3䛛᭶䛾
ຠ⏝್
4$/<ੰෲपउऐॊ୯ીവधઊठજॉ
z
6䛛᭶䛾 …
ຠ⏝್
HOR-001
1
0.4
YES
0.8
0.7
Ṛஸᚋ
HOR-002
2
1.2
YES
0.7
0.8
0.4
…
HOR-003
2
0.6
YES
0.8
Ḟ 0.7
…
HOR-004
1
1.5
NO
0.9
0.8
1.0
…
HOR-005
2
1.1
NO
0.7
0.7
0.9
…
HOR-006
1
2.3
NO
0.7
0.8
0.4
…
HOR-007
1
0.3
YES
0.5
0.6
Ṛஸᚋ
…
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
䞉䞉䞉
z
10
…
ຠ⏝್
z
㏣㊧⤊
1
z
᭤⥺㠃✚
䠙ᡴ䛱ษ䜚QALY
ऒभॹॱشऊै೩ओधप4$/<॑ੑखथ
ණૻຎ॑खञः
ઌभেோফਯऋ୯ીവৎਡ
भফਯेॉশःऒधमॎऊॊ
ණ௴ؚেோফਯؚଈಝથ૮৽ؚৎ৷க
z
ଈಝऽञमঢ়ੱभँॊৎਡप୯ऋીവघॊ
धઌभ4$/<मਂ
েோফਯभઊठજॉ
ઌभ4$/<ऋ୯ીവৎਡऽ
दभ4$/<ेॉপऌःऒधम
ॎऊॊ
0
4$/<भઊठજॉ
ᡴ䛱ษ䜚ᚋ䛾ຠ⏝್
䛿0௨ୖ䛸௬ᐃ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
11
12
๕ऩॹॱشभেோফਯप
.DSODQ0HLHU১॑ి৷
ઊठજॉॹॱشभଁੑੰෲ
z
েோৎੰෲधखथன
㻝㻚㻜
z
ঽேऩૢ৷
েோৎੰෲু১दઊठજॉ4$/<॑ੰෲ
¾ .DSODQ0HLHU১ऩन॑ి৷
"
"
z
㻜㻚㻤
⏕Ꮡྜ
.DSODQ0HLHU১ؚটॢছথॡਫ਼&ؚR[షؼؚ
㻜㻚㻢
,,,, ,
,,, , ,
,,,,, ,
㻜㻚㻠
㻜㻚㻞
z
,,, ,,,
,,
,,
4$/<भଁੑੰෲषभ.DSODQ0HLHU১ऩनभ
ి৷मඦप
୯॑ਢऐञधऌभઌभ
েோফਯऋॎऊढञधघॊ
.DSODQ0HLHUශमઌभ
েோශ॑ેী๚
, , ,,,
, ,,,,
,, ,,,
,, ,
, ,,,, ,,,,,
,, , ,, ,,,, , ,,
,, ,,,,
,,
, ,
, , ,,,
,, ,
,,,,,,
,, , , , ,,, ,
, ,,
㻷㼍㼜㼘㼍㼚㻙㻹㼑㼕㼑㼞᭤⥺
┿䛾⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ䛾ศᕸ
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻡
㻝㻚㻜
㻝㻚㻡
㻞㻚㻜
㻞㻚㻡
㻟㻚㻜
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
13
14
๕ऩॹॱشभ4$/<प
.DSODQ0HLHU১॑ి৷
㻽㻭㻸㼅䛾⏕Ꮡྜ
㻝㻚㻜
,
,,
,
,
,
㻜㻚㻤
,
㻽㻭㻸㼅䛾㻷㼍㼜㼘㼍㼚㻙㻹㼑㼕㼑㼞᭤⥺
┿䛾㻽㻭㻸㼅䛾ศᕸ
,,,
,,,
,
㻜㻚㻢
ලऩदઅइथाॊ
,,
,,,
,, ,
㻜㻚㻠
z
,
,,
,
,,, ,,
, ,
,,
,,,,
,,
,,
, ,
,,,,,, ,,,,
, , ,,
,,
,
,,,,
,
,,,, , ,, , ,,
,,,
,,, , ,
㻜㻚㻞
z
.DSODQ0HLHUශमઌभ
4$/<॑পऌऎ
4$/<ਰभસ়
¾ YV
,, ,, ,,
,
,
,
,,
,
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻡
㻝㻚㻜
㻝㻚㻡
㻞㻚㻜
ऺनभ๕ऩॹॱشऊैয॑௷ऌলघ
৷கमৎधधुप৲खऩः೩
㻞㻚㻡
㻟㻚㻜
୯॑ਢऐञधऌभমਊभেோফਯऋॎऊढञधघॊ
ᝈ⪅ID
⩌
┿䛾
ほᐹ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ ⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
Ṛஸ
䛒䜚
ຠ⏝್
┿䛾
QALY
ほᐹ
QALY
1.8
A 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.9
2.7
B 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.5
1.5
1.0
C 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.2
0.6
0.4
D 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
0.9
2.7
2.7
E 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
0.5
1.5
1.5
F 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
0.2
0.6
0.6
㻽㻭㻸㼅
15
ऩछ.DSODQ0HLHU১द4$/<भীഘ॑
ਫखऎदऌऩःभऊ
z
ਖमઊठજैोञ೩भඞः্
z
⩌
┿䛾
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
ほᐹ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
Ṛஸ
䛒䜚
ຠ⏝್
┿䛾
QALY
ほᐹ
QALY
A 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.9
2.7
1.8
B 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.5
1.5
1.0
C 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
0.2
0.6
0.4
z
௴4$/<मઌभ4$/<॑⋈
4$/<दमੲਾभँॊઊठજॉ
.DSODQ0HLHU১मੲਾभऩःઊठજॉ॑ෘ
৷கऋঢ়બघॊ4$/<भଁੑੰෲदमਛॉয়ञऩः
Cox et al. JRSS A 1992.
z
भෙॉ়ংॖ॔५भপऌऔ
ઊठજॉभऋःऺनؚপऌः
೩द৷கप୷ऋँॊऺनؚপऌः
䐠
௴েோফਯमઌभেோফਯ॑खऩः⋇
েோফਯदमੲਾभऩःઊठજॉ
ऩछ.DSODQ0HLHU১द4$/<भীഘ॑
ਫखऎदऌऩःभऊ
z
ᝈ⪅ID
䐟
16
¾ ৢଞؚ4$/<॑পऌऎৄुॊ্भংॖ॔५
z
્पିਔघसऌ૾ய
ණदেோফਯृ৷கभীഘऋ౮ऩॊৃ়
¾ ණૻຎभपংॖ॔५ऋৼ௨औोऩः
17
18
ৌ૪১؟,3&:১
ઊठજैोऩःન૨भ
,QYHUVH3UREDELOLW\RI&HQVRULQJ:HLJKWHG১
ઊठજैोञ೩भॹऺ॑ॱشऊभ೩ऋ๛৻ॎॉ
z
$)عऔ॒भॹॱشभઊठજैोऩःન૨
عফ؟
عফ؟
¾ ')عऔ॒मযী
ੰෲष൴
ᝈ⪅ID
⩌
┿䛾
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
ほᐹ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
Ṛஸ
䛒䜚
A 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
B 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
C 䛥䜣
1
3
2
NO
D 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
E 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
F 䛥䜣
1
3
3
YES
েோফਯदੲਾभऩःઊठજॉभৃ়
z
ઊठજैोऩःન૨भಗਯदઊठજैोथःऩः
ॹ॑ॱشातऐघॊ্১ Zhao et al. Biometrika 1997.
ઊठજॉ॑ॖঋথॺधखञ.DSODQ0HLHU১द
ᡴ䛱ษ䜙䜜䛺䛔☜⋡
z
㻝㻚㻜
,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,, ,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,, ,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,, ,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, , ,,,,,, ,,,,, ,,,,,,,,, ,,,,, ,,
,,,,
,
,,,
,,
,,,,,,
,,
㻜㻚㻤
,,,,
,
,
,,
,
, ,,,
,,
,, ,
, ,
㻜㻚㻢
㻜㻚㻠
,,
,, ,
,
,
ઊठજैोऩःન૨
,
,,
,
,, ,
,,
¾ ফ؟
ফ؟
¾ ফ؟ফ؟
㻜㻚㻞
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻡
㻝㻚㻜
㻝㻚㻡
,
,
,,
,
㻞㻚㻜
㻞㻚㻡
㻟㻚㻜
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
19
20
๕ऩॹॱشप,3&:১॑ి৷
㻽㻭㻸㼅䛾⏕Ꮡྜ
㻝㻚㻜
,
,,
,
,
,
㻜㻚㻤
,
㻜㻚㻢
㻵㻼㻯㼃ἲ
㻷㼍㼜㼘㼍㼚㻙㻹㼑㼕㼑㼞ἲ
┿䛾㻽㻭㻸㼅䛾ศᕸ
,,,
,,,
,
,,
,,,
,, ,
হदभଁੑੰෲभ੶ൗગ
,
,,
㻜㻚㻠
,
,,, ,,
, ,
,,
,,,,
,,
,,
z
, ,
,,,,,, ,,,,
, , ,,
,,
,
,,,,
,
,,,, , ,, , ,,
,,,
,,, , ,
㻜㻚㻞
z We used inverse probability weighting to
estimate the mean […] QALYs, accounting for
the censored nature of these data.
z The weights were evaluated as the inverse of
Kaplan Meier estimator of censoring probability.
z For QALYs […], we partitioned the study time
horizon in homogenous subintervals (quarterly
intervals) […]
z Linear regression was used […]. We included
baseline EQ-5D scores as a covariate in the
estimation of QALYs.
,3&:১मઌभ4$/<भী
ഘपปअ
೩ਯऋऐोयಱ
,, ,, ,,
,
,
,
,,
,
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻜
㻜㻚㻡
㻝㻚㻜
㻝㻚㻡
㻞㻚㻜
㻞㻚㻡
㻟㻚㻜
㻽㻭㻸㼅
21
ଢ଼॑ীસखथ,3&:১॑ి৷
z
ຠ⏝್
1
4$/< 4भ4भ
4भ4भ
ؚؚؚऊাऽदઊठજैोऩःન૨॑
ઊठજैोथःऩः4f4॑ातऐੰෲ
ಖ২भऋୄऔोॊ
22
ණद॔থংছথ५ऩऊা৯भ৷க
z
(4'५॥॔भ
0䛛᭶
3䛛᭶
6䛛᭶
9䛛᭶
12䛛᭶
䝬䝂䝑䝖⒪ἲ⩌
0.485
0.556
0.592
0.585
0.595
䝝䜲䝗䝻䝀䝹⩌
0.539
0.559
0.566
0.628
0.625
ऊা৯दঁॖॻট।ঝණभ্ऋऺनৈः
ছথॲ৲मखथःॊऋؚ4$/<षभ୶প
Manca et al. Health Econ 2005.
z
Q2
Q1
0
3䛛᭶
Q3
6䛛᭶
၉ேभုॉभ৹ତ
Q4
9䛛᭶
ঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତ
ಖ২؞ਫ਼লৡभ
12䛛᭶
Ramsey et al. Value Health 2015.
¾ फ़ॖॻছॖথदम৹ତ॑ਘऎਏ
⏕Ꮡᖺᩘ
23
24
ৌ૪১؟4$/<भషীෲ
z
,3&:১॑৷ःञाહऌష
ଵ
¾ Żණؚ
ߚଵଵ
ଶ
ଵ ଵ
হदभ4$/<भੰෲટ
z
12䛛᭶䜎䛷䛾ᖹᆒQALY
(95% ಙ㢗༊㛫)
ଶ ଶ
Żঋش५ছॖথ৷க
䝬䝂䝑䝖⒪ἲ⩌
ߚଶଵ ߚଷଵ ߚସଵ
¾ ऊাऽदभ4$/<भ৹ତੋाණ୷
৬पमਰৣभ॑ੑ
¾ࢼ
ൌ σୀଵ
ఋೖ
ீ ೖ
ࢄ ࢄ்
ିଵ
σୀଵ
ऊাऽदभ4$/<पණ୷मऩः
䝝䜲䝗䝻䝀䝹⩌
⩌㛫ᕪ
Willan et al. Stat Med 2005.
0.540 (0.489, 0.589)
0.011 (í0.067, 0.071)
ઊठજॉؚঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତੋा
¾ ঋش५ছॖথ৷க॑৹ତखऩऊढञै
ఋೖ ொೖ
ࢄ
ீ ೖ
ݐઊठજॉपৌघॊ.DSODQ0HLHU
¾ܩ
¾ ߜ યƎभॖঋথॺંਯؚܺ યƎभઊठજॉન૨௬ৎਡ
0.551 (0.505, 0.591)
उजैऎණ୷भਡகम
z
ા৷ટীෲदमَા৷ৌટमಉُध
25
26
4$/<ੰෲदभ୯ਸभଁੑਵ
z
ऽधी
ા৷ટীෲपउऐॊા৷भଁੑੰෲ
z
4$/<धभॹॱشଡୗ
ા৷
ෙढञभതो
ਜ਼ৎਊञॉभા৷ ¼ েோফਯ
৷க ¼ েோফਯ
ిજऩੰෲ১भऱधणम,3&:১
¾ 4$/<
z
ઊठજॉ॑ൣअ4$/<भଁੑੰෲ
.DSODQ0HLHU১ऩनभఏऩেோৎੰෲু১दम
েோফਯभਗዠ
z
ঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତੰෲ
5&7भ୯म
၉ேभုॉ॑৹ତ
ଁੑपളහदुୖؚः
,3&:১
ಖ২؞ਫ਼লৡभ
ા৷ટীෲदीैोॊऒधऋः
¾
షীෲद
અ/DWLPHU11,&(76'
27
અધ൴
z
z
হ
8HQR,RND 7,NHGD0HWDO5DQGRPL]HGSKDVH,,,VWXG\RIJHPFLWDELQHSOXV66
DORQHRUJHPFLWDELQHDORQHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKORFDOO\DGYDQFHGDQGPHWDVWDWLFSDQFUHDWLF
FDQFHULQ-DSDQDQG7DLZDQ*(676WXG\-&OLQ 2QFRO 'XPYLOOH -&:RUWK\*%ODQG-0 HWDO/DUYDOWKHUDS\IRUOHJXOFHUV9HQ86 ,,
UDQGRPLVHG FRQWUROOHGWULDO%0-E
6RDUHV02,JOHVLDV&3%ODQG-0HWDO&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVRIODUYDOWKHUDS\IRU
OHJXOFHUV%0-E
ઊठજॉ॑ൣअ4$/<؞ા৷दभ,3&:১
&R['5)LW]SDWULFN5)OHWFKHU$(HWDO4XDOLW\RIOLIHDVVHVVPHQW&DQZHNHHSLW
VLPSOH"-56WDWLVW6RF $
=KDR+7VLDWLV$$$&RQVLVWHQWHVWLPDWRUIRUWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRITXDOLW\DGMXVWHG
VXUYLYDOWLPH%LRPHWLULND
YDQGHU/DDQ0-+XEEDUG$/RFDOO\HIILFLHQWHVWLPDWLRQRIWKHTXDOLW\DGMXVWHGOLIHWLPH
GLVWULEXWLRQZLWKULJKWFHQVRUHGGDWDDQGFRYDULDWHV%LRPHWULFV
:LOODQ $5/LQ'<&RRN5-HWDO8VLQJLQYHUVHZHLJKWLQJLQFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLV
ZLWKFHQVRUHGGDWD6WDW0HWKRGV0HG5HV
:LOODQ$5%ULJJV$+6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVRIFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVGDWD:LOH\
%DQJ+7VLDWLV$$(VWLPDWLQJPHGLFDOFRVWVZLWKFHQVRUHGGDWD%LRPHWULND
28
અધ൴
4$/<भঋش५ছॖথ৷கदभ৹ତ
0DQFD$+DZNLQV16FXOSKHU0-(VWLPDWLQJPHDQ4$/<VLQWULDOEDVHGFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVV
DQDO\VLVWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIFRQWUROOLQJIRUEDVHOLQHXWLOLW\+HDOWK(FRQ
5DPVH\6':LOONH5-*OLFN+HWDO&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVDORQJVLGHFOLQLFDOWULDOV,,
$Q,6325JRRGUHVHDUFKSUDFWLFHVWDVNIRUFHUHSRUW9DOXH+HDOWK
z
4$/<؞ા৷भ,3&:షীෲ
/LQ'</LQHDUUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVRIFHQVRUHGPHGLFDOFRVWV%LRVWDWLVWLFV
:LOODQ $5/LQ'<0DQFD $5HJUHVVLRQPHWKRGVIRUFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVZLWK
FHQVRUHGGDWD6WDW0HG
$QGUHL$0XUUD\65HJUHVVLRQPHWKRGVIRUWKHPHDQRIWKHTXDOLW\RIOLIHDGMXVWHG
UHVWULFWHGVXUYLYDOWLPHXVLQJSVHXGRREVHUYDWLRQV%LRPHWULFV
7XQHVGD6LOYD*.OHLQ-35HJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVRIPHDQTXDOLW\DGMXVWHGVXUYLYDOWLPHEDVHG
RQSVHXGRREVHUYDWLRQV6WDW0HG
z
েோঢ়ਯभਗዠ
/DWLPHU11,&('68WHFKQLFDOVXSSRUWGRFXPHQW6XUYLYDODQDO\VLVIRUHFRQRPLF
HYDOXDWLRQVDORQJVLGHFOLQLFDOWULDOVH[WUDSRODWLRQZLWKSDWLHQWOHYHOGDWD
/DWLPHU156XUYLYDODQDO\VLVIRUHFRQRPLFHYDOXDWLRQVDORQJVLGHFOLQLFDOWULDOV
([WUDSRODWLRQZLWKSDWLHQWOHYHOGDWD,QFRQVLVWHQFLHVOLPLWDWLRQVDQGDSUDFWLFDOJXLGH0HG
'LVF0DNLQJ
%DJXVW $%HDOH66XUYLYDODQDO\VLVDQGH[WUDSRODWLRQPRGHOLQJRIWLPHWRHYHQWFOLQLFDOWULDO
GDWDIRUHFRQRPLFHYDOXDWLRQ$QDOWHUQDWLYHDSSURDFK0HG'LVF0DNLQJ
-DFNVRQ&6WHYHQV-5HQ6HWDO([WUDSRODWLQJVXUYLYDOIURPUDQGRPL]HGWULDOVXVLQJ
H[WHUQDOGDWD$UHYLHZRIPHWKRGV0HG'LVF0DNLQJ>(SXE DKHDGRISULQW@
z
© Copyright 2026 ExpyDoc
