液体キセノンのシンチレーション光に感度のある大型MPPCの

Status of the Development of MPPC for
LXe detector Upgrade
Daisuke Kaneko
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor
Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
0
1
Reminder 1
Application to LXe
detector
Sensitivity to VUV
(λ=175nm)
1 p.e. resolve with
12x12㎟
0 p.e.
Photon Detection Efficiency
25%
3x3 ㎟ (2012-5)
12x12 ㎟ (2012-12)
20%
12x12 ㎟ (2013-2)
15%
10%
5%
0%
0
1 p.e.
1
2
Over Voltage [V]
2 p.e.
Long tail
(τ~200ns)
How to reduce long tail ?
Target is about 50ns (~Scintillation decay)
Worse S/N
Increase pileup
etc.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
2
Reminder 2
• Reduce quench resistance
as low as possible.
• Reduce input resistance of
amplifier
Tail is not be
reduced than
expected with
lower quench
Decay constant [ns]
How to reduce long tail of 12×12㎟ MPPC ?
400
300
200
100
0
10
• Divide and connect in
series active sensor area
100
1000
10000
Quench resistance [kΩ]
Waveform is
distorted with long
coaxial cable
200ns
Most realistic plan
The effect was confirmed at
room temperature test.
Rs = 33Ω, 10m cable
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
3
Serial connection of MPPC
Reduce sensor capacitance by subdividing 12mm×12mm of active
sensor region.
palarel:𝐶 = 𝑐 + 𝑐 + 𝑐 + 𝑐 = 4𝑐
serial:𝐶 =
1
1
+
𝑐
𝑐
1
𝑐
+ +
1 −1
𝑐
=
𝑐
4
Signal is expected to be sharpened due to smaller capacitance,
while there is anxiety that S/N become worse.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Serial connection test at room temp.
Set up for room temp. test
4
Observed Waveform
MPP
C
LED light, averaged
4 serial
30ns
2serial,2parallel 50
ns
4parallel 200ns
LED
mask
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
5
Set up for LXe temp. test
We tested 2 types of connection
Simple serial and Hybrid connection in
LXe.
Simple serial connection
6mm
Hybrid connection
Serial – signal
Parallel - bias
preamp
bias
○ Less parts
× Extra parts
○ Automatically over
voltage is adjusted
× Gain uniformity
is required
× 4 times higher
voltage
○ Same voltage as
single MPPC
× Voltage difference
between each sector
○ All sectors have
common voltage
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
6
Assembly work
Every time the xenon chamber needed to be
open to modify connection of MPPCs.
MPP
C
LED
Yuki Nakai
from Kyushu
univ.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
7
Waveform of 1 photo electron
Hybrid 4segments
V→
Flashing LED and trigger with
synchronized pulse.
Vov = 3.0V
Hybrid 2segments
Vov = 3.0V
Simple
• Waveform is as sharp
as 3×3㎟ MPPCs
• 1 p.e. signal can be
resolved
0 p.e.
1 p.e.
Vov = 3.0V
2 p.e.
Simple
3.0V
Parallel
Vov =1.5V
×10 amp
t→
charge →
Baseline RMS have no significant
difference, ~2mV
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
How many segments to divide
We tested 4 & 2 segments.
4 segments (C/16)
2 segments (C/4)
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
8
9
Gain (multiplication factor)
Gain is 4~10×105
2 segments
Gain is lower as
capacitance is smaller.
Amplitude is almost the
same.
4 segments
Lower than that of
parallel connection, but
1 p.e. is still resolved
with proper voltage.
C = e × Gain / V Hybrid1 : 18.7 ±1.9 [fF]
Hybrid2 : 32.9 ±0.4 [fF]
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Decay time and Connection type
Calculated decay constant by
fitting waveform by event.
4 segments 25ns
2 segments 46ns
↕
Parallel 200ns
2 segments
4 segments
50ns of target time constant is
achieved in both cases.
Estimated time constant (τ = RC) from 1.20MΩ quench resistance and
previous capacitance C
4 segments : 22.4ns
2 segments : 39.4ns
Consistent to observation within
about 20% error.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
10
Leading edge and connection type
Leading time constant is also
shorter in smaller
capacitance.
4 segments
2 segments
Leading time constant seems
to depend on o.v. , fitting for
small waveform was difficult.
↓
To use pico sec pulse laser, Hamamatsu PLP-10 400nm.
Available soon.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
11
12
Effect of long cable
In MEG LXe detector, long coaxial cable of about 10m exists
between sensor and read-out electronics.
2 segments
4 segments
Cable Length [m]
Gain does not change, while decay time slightly increases (1ns/m).
Constant is 56ns at 11m of 2 segments, but still acceptable.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
13
Summary of serial connection
Gain
(@ 3V)
Peak
separation
Noise rms
[mV]
Decay
const [ns]
Rise
const [ns]
4 segments
4×105
○
2.0 – 2.5
25 ~ 33
2–3
2 segments
8×105
◎
2.0 – 2.5
46 ~ 56
4-5
Gain is larger and peak is clearer when number of segment is few.
This makes charge calibration easier and relative gain error smaller.
On the other hand, signal is sharper with finer segmentation. Timing
resolution is expected to be better, and pile-up will be reduced.
4 segments is favorable, because gain error is small enough, and timing
resolution should be as good as possible. In addition, if single p.e. can not be
resolved, it is easier to switch 2 segments.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Package design (preliminary)
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
14
15
PCB based feedthrough
Slope (Charge/Voltage)
Charges of 1 p.e. event are
compared between usual
LEMO-connector and PCB
feedthroughs.
= 100.8 ± 1.2 [fF] LEMO
= 103.0 ± 2.0 [fF] MMCX
About for charge, there is no difference.
Another properties are being analyzed.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Summary and prospects
16
Comment
Several types of serial connection were tested Hamamatsu
in LXe.
・30 – 50 ns of decay constant was achieved.
Low PDE of previous sample
・Single p.e. can be resolved
was caused by a unwanted layer
on surface, and this layer can be
All basic requirements to MPPC were satisfied
removed by some process.
Hybrid, 4-segment connection is advantageous
forsamples
main design
New
arrive soon
Next to do
Confirm improvement of PDE in new technology MPPC.
MC simulation with concrete MPPC parameters.
Detailed assembly design of detector and prototype.
Preparation of prototype test.
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Fin.
現MEGにおける液体キセノン検出器
18
μ+→e + γ 崩壊で発生する
52.8MeVのγ線を検出する。
900ℓの液体キセノン (LXe)
PMT
Present
入射面に216個
他の面に630個の
有効面積の直径が46mmの
光電子増倍管(PMT)
γ-ray
PMT に近い位置でγが反応した場合、光
子の収集効率に場所依存性が大きくな
る。
↓
検出器の浅い位置では分解能が悪い。
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
19
液体キセノン検出器の更新
より小型のセンサーを入射面に
配置してuniformityを良くし
て、分解能を向上させる
PMT
MPPC
Upgraded
CG image
γ
γ-ray
←現在
更新後→
浜松ホトニクス製のピクセル
光検出器(MPPC)を採用する予定
入射面に約4000個の
紫外線に感度があり有感面積
12×12mm2を持つMPPC
γ
xenon
volume
acceptance
入射面の幅を広げる
→
エネルギー漏れが減少
光電面を同平面上に
→
レスポンスがより均一に
International Seminar→
on Lepton Flavor
Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
入射前の物質量が減少
検出効率が向上(約10%)
20
シャワーの見え方の違い
現在
更新後
MCによる、同一のγ線パイルアップイベント
イメージング能力が格段に向上
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
更新後の性能
depth ≧ 2cm
60 % of events
depth < 2cm
40 % of events
Upgraded
Present
21
エネルギー分解能
σup
2.4%
↓
1.1%
Upgraded
Present
σup
1.7%
↓
1.0%
52.8MeV(MEGで探索する信号)に対する応答
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Position resolution in σ [mm]
更新後の性能
位置分解能
Red : Present
Blue : Upgraded
Depth from inner face [cm]
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
22
23
Raw-Waveform
25μ
Low Rq
50μ
Low Rq
25μ
Mid Rq
50μ
Mid Rq
25μ
High Rq
50μ
High Rq
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
pre amplifier
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
24
25
Result : Waveform and Quench-R
Fitting waveforms with a doubleexponential function works well.
・The tail time constant do not
depend on Rq so much
・25µm pitch MPPC is not so
different from 50µm.
MPPC Type
50
25
Quench
R [kΩ]
Over voltage [V]
R1 Low
349
R2 Mid
606
R3 High
8867
Over voltage [V]
R1 Low
719
R2 Mid
1170
R3 High
21433
1 Rising & 1 Trailing
component, τr ,τt
Trail time constant
τt [ns]
1.0
246
277
2.0
-
1.2
255
288
783
2.5
214
218
538
1.5
276
314
3.0
-
Rise time constant
τr [ns]
1.0
19.6
19
2.0
-
1.2
21
19.4
16.5
2.5
20.7
20.1
23.5
1.5
24.3
20.7
3.0
-
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
26
How to shorten waveform
Smaller Rs
→ Effective, but only in limited situation.
↓Data taken with large-area MPPC at room temperature↓
τt= 192 ns
Rs = 50Ω
short
cable
τt= 138 ns
Rs = 33Ω
short
cable
Rs = 33Ω
long cable
Tail is reduced with small Rs, but the waveform is distorted with
a long read-out cable because of the impedance mismatch.
Smaller Rp
→ Not effective
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
Cause of long waveform
Waveform can not be shortened
only by reducing the quench
resistance and cell capacitance.
MPPC side
27
AMP side
Vb
Rp
bias voltage
protect
resistance
amplifier
quench
resistance
Rq
Cd
diode
(sensor)
Rs
…
C
shunt
resistance
s
stray
capacitance
Rs,Rp×Cs term is dominant
against Rq×Cd term under
small Rq condition?
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
28
90%
80%
70%
Total
60%
H window 4
50%
H window 3
40%
H window 2
30%
H window 1
relative charge
80
100%
70
60
50
40
30
20
20%
10
10%
0
0%
269
271
0
273
5
10
15
capacitance [nf]
Tail constant
267
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
5
10
15
capacitance [nf]
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
29
Set up for LXe temp. test
We tested 2 types of connection
Simple serial and Hybrid connection
6mm
Simple serial connection
Hybrid I (4 sectors)
Hybrid II (2 sectors)
preamp
○ Less parts
× Extra parts
○ Automatically
over
bias
voltage is adjusted
× Gain uniformity
is required
× 4 times higher
voltage
○ Same voltage as
single MPPC
× voltage difference
between each sector
○ All sectors have
common voltage
Actual test was done with 3 MPPCs
because 1 sample was broken
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
1 p.e. ピークの広がり
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam
30
31
Detailed PDE calculation of G-type MPPC
Voltage
In 2013Feb-1 test 130150UM-R2
PDE
1.7
Errors
25%
type-I
3x3 ㎟ (12年5月)
12x12 ㎟ (12年12月)
12x12 ㎟ (13年2月)
20%
1.4
Gain
3.1%
1.6%
Alpha peak
0.26%
0.21%
Correction
3.2%
1.7%
Model syst. 14%
22%
total
22.2%
15.3%
15%
10%
voltage
1.4
1.7
PDE
+/-
15.5
2.5
16.9
3.7
5%
0%
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
Over Voltage [V]
International Seminar on Lepton Flavor Physics with Most Intense DC Muon Beam